Minister Mantashe ignores the plight of the Poor while batting for the Rich.



In response to the recent court judgement in the Pretoria High Court, Minister Mantashe lamented the ruling, claiming that “the community of Xolobeni needs mining in order to bring about much-needed development in the area” and that “mining is being treated like a curse rather than a blessing. It is not treated as a wealth, it is treated as more of a negative. It is a polluter, it is a depravation and all that. That worries me a great deal because the mining we have, we are endowed with it naturally. We should just be forced to mine responsibly.”

Minister Mantashe`s comments capture in a few short sentences the essence of why conflict between mining companies and communities have become so pervasive and why communities have been forced to resort to the courts in the face of a deep chasm of understanding between government and the people, whose interest’s government is supposed to represent.

The assertion by the Minister that mining will bring development and other benefits to communities does not stand up to any kind of scrutiny and flies in the face of the lived reality of those affected by mining.

ActionAid South Africa, in collaboration with Mining Affected Communities United in Action (MACUA) and Women Affected by Mining United in Action (WAMUA) have conducted social audits in 10 communities affected by mining across 8 provinces and our preliminary findings suggest that the Minister is out of touch
with the true costs of mining.


Our research, which will be published in the first quarter of 2019, points to a government who has abandoned affected communities to the mercy of corporate trickle-down development while the bulk of any corporate social responsibility and development money and benefit disappears into the vacuum of politically and economically connected elites leaving the vast majority stuck in a vicious cycle of poverty.



Among some of the most startling findings of our research we found that according to PWC reports that have been compiled for Johannesburg Stock Exchange listed corporate entities within the South African Mining Industry since 2009 and incorporating financial results from 2007, the South African Mining Industry has, despite a consistent media narrative in which the mining industry corporates are cast as victims struggling to make a profit,  accumulated net profits of R221 Billion Rands over this period.
 
The declared profits do not include the undeclared illicit financial flows which the African Monitor claims peaked at R237 Billion per annum in 2011. According to the African Monitor, South Africa has lost a cumulative R1,007 Billion to illicit outflows between 2002 and 2011.

The state on the other hand, remains a significant beneficiary of the mining regime as it is currently configured and the same PWC report series from 2009 to June 2018, suggest that the state has received R160 billion in direct tax revenues during this period. An additional amount of approximately R45 billion is estimated to be paid to government as Royalties. In all, the PWC reports (which do not factor in any potential mis-invoicing and/or illicit financial flows) estimate that government takes approximately 24% of value reported among the listed JSE mining corporates, employees 47% of value reported and shareholders, 29% of value reported. Community investments by contrast has only amounted to 0.9% over the same period.

But, as has been shown in this report, none of the value from these community investments are experienced in the lived realities of affected communities who participated in this survey. Up to 79% of respondents in our survey, those to whom these benefits are meant to accrue, have not participated in or benefited from the claimed investments.

73% of respondents indicated that there were no individuals in their household who either held a job at the mine or who was previously employed by the mine. Of the 27% of respondents who indicated that there were individuals from their household who had either previously been or currently are employed at the mine, 41% indicated that they were casual manual jobs on a   piecemeal or contract basis, with a further 60 respondents or 33% describing the employment as other.

While each community had specific concerns which were directly related to their lived reality, the aggregate themes which emerged from the responses indicate that environmental issues, such as air, land and water pollution, which impacts on human and livestock health, soil and water quality, were by far the greatest concern across the mining communities surveyed.

Concerns about environmental impacts were closely followed by concerns around the unsafe environment produced by mining activities. These relate to concerns about blasting tremors and damage to houses caused by the blasting as well as rising crime within communities.

Following from the environmental concerns and to some extent the concerns about a generally unsafe environment, the issue of health, ranging from TB and HIV to rash and skin infections and concerns about asthma, silicosis and chest and lung problems and Cancer are some of the issues highlighted by respondents.

The data and responses from respondents suggest that immediate health and safety concerns outweighed issues of corruption and accountability even though the theme of corruption, nepotism and lack of accountability was consistent throughout the surveyed communities.

As one respondent put it: “they do not employ the community and also our community is now medically unfit due to chemicals that our mine is using and they do not even supply us with skills development centres - People are unable to independently access livelihood opportunities after getting sick at the mines.”

So, while mining is an enormously profitable enterprise for some, it is curse for others. What the Minister misses in his lament is the fact that the mining industry has been and continues under his leadership, to operate irresponsibly and by so doing they continue to alienate thousands of communities as it slashes a destructive path through the natural environment and social fabric of South African society while the politically connected laugh all the way to bank.

Unless a more just mining regime is negotiated for impacted communities, the Minister will have to accept that he will face more court challenges and more conflict on the ground.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Selling the Family Silver: Power, Extraction, and the False Promise of Balance in South Africa’s Political Economy

Image
  Introduction: Davos , Washington , and the Pedagogy of Humiliation There is something quietly revealing about South Africa’s annual pilgrimage to Davos. There, amid the rituals of elite networking and the theatre of global consensus, South African leaders encounter the realities of power stripped of ceremony: conditional access, asymmetrical bargaining, and the expectation of compliance dressed up as partnership.  It is an experience uncomfortably familiar to those lower down the domestic hierarchy; mining-affected communities, the working poor, and those whose lives are shaped by decisions taken elsewhere and justified after the fact. The irony is not that South Africa is treated poorly at Davos or in Washington, but that its political leadership appears perpetually surprised when it is. When President Ramaphosa travelled to Washington and was treated as an inconvenience rather than a partner, some commentators rushed to frame the moment as an aberration, a function of Donald...
Read more

The Madlanga Commission Must Not Ignore the Billion-Rand Smoking Gun.

Image
    A billion-rand policing operation may have been guided not by crime intelligence or public-safety imperatives, but by a government apparatus whose strategic orientation has become increasingly indistinguishable from the corporate mining lobby and criminal interests. When MACUA submitted evidence to the Madlanga Commission raising serious concerns about the evidence that had emerged in the Madlanga Commission about Operation Vala Umgodi and the deaths in Stilfontein, the Commission acknowledged receipt, but its hearings have yet to reflect any engagement with the issues raised. Instead, the inquiry has focused almost exclusively on the Political Killings Task Team (PKTT) and the Ekhurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department . To an extent, this is understandable. The Commission was established in response to allegations by General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi that the PKTT had been disbanded due to improper links between senior politicians and criminal syndicates. The inquiry was b...
Read more

South Africa Must Defend Its Sovereign Wealth, Before It’s All Sold to the Highest Bidder

Image
  When Anglo American Plc announced its plan to merge with Canada’s Teck Resources and relocate its holding structure to Vancouver, it was not merely another corporate transaction. It was a seismic act of capital flight, the slow-motion exit of one of South Africa’s most historically powerful corporations, taking with it a century’s worth of accumulated wealth, expertise, and control over our national mineral assets. As economist DumaGqubule outlines in his recently released report, The Anglo–Teck Merger: A Global Power Play , this deal is not about efficiency or synergy; it is about jurisdiction. It is about where wealth will be controlled, where taxes will be paid, and where accountability will end. It is a reminder that, despite our constitutional commitment to economic sovereignty, South Africa still lacks the institutional and legislative backbone to protect its sovereign mineral wealth from transnational looting disguised as “global investment.” While Canada has built ...
Read more